Get the real story via our monthly newsletter

Search

    2
    0

rss

Send to a colleague

Home > Commentary > Trends Archive > The 6 Million Dollar WYSIWYG Editor

Browse TrendWatch Blog

Recent Blog Entries

The Complete Archive

Trends by Vendor


TrendWatch by Channel

Web Content Management Trends

Enterprise Portals Trends

ECM Trends

Web Analytics Trends

Enterprise Search Trends

SharePoint Trends

Digital & Media Asset Management Trends

XML & Component Content Management Trends

E-mail Archiving & Management Trends


Report Excerpt

The Web CMS Report 2008 looks at... Magnolia

"However, one important point to note here is that unlike other systems, the content is created from the perspective of the published web pages. So you first have to define pages and then add paragraphs using submitted content. In other words, Magnolia is, comparatively, a very page-oriented system. As elsewhere, we'll argue this is not a bad thing, because most web editors think that way and most websites (especially simpler sites) work that way. However, if you plan more intensive content component reuse, this system may not be ideal. "

(p. 747)

More about The Web CMS Report 2008

Our customers say

"The Web CMS Report is excellent! Very well written, and you've done a masterful job explaining the business case for WCM.
- - Peter Morville,
Consultant, Author, Information Architecture for the World Wide Web

NEW at CMS Watch

The ECM Suites Report 2009 The ECM Suites Report 2009: This report evaluates 30 ECM offerings... Read more
ECM Education ECM Technology Online Courses: Alan Pelz-Sharpe instructs students on ECM Technology...Read more
jboye08 Join us in Denmark at jboye08: On November 4, CMS Watch will teach tutorials on Web Content Management, Enterprise Social Software, and SharePoint... Read more

 

TrendWatch Blog

The 6 Million Dollar WYSIWYG Editor

28-Oct-2006

OK, I’m exaggerating. I’ve never actually seen a 6 million dollar WYSIWYG (What You See Is What You Get) editor. But, I have seen a 2 million dollar WYSIWYG editor and multitudes of them in the 100K – 500K price range. When we work with clients regarding web operational concerns, I always ask to see any incumbent content management systems -- and sometimes I see some big expensive ones. What’s really sad is that when I ask why they purchased a pricey system in the first place, frequently the response is that they wanted to be able to “lock down” certain aspects of a page, such as the global navigation or the header and footer. They were sick of casual contributors making modifications to a page that weren’t in line with the corporate style guidelines -- technically known as “making ugly pages.” Yet, all that was really required was the enforcement of web standards and a customizable WYSIWYG editor with some “template lite” functionality. I don’t know who’s at fault here. Is it the organization that doesn’t want to take the basic work of web standards enforcement seriously – either out of lack of managerial courage or ignorance? Or, is it the CMS vendor who sells an organization a Rolls Royce CMS when they know full-well that the problem could be solved much more easily and cheaply with some Toyota Echo web editing software. Whatever the case: shame on everyone.

- Submitted by: Lisa Welchman, Guest Analyst

All CMS Channel Trends

Join the conversation

Digg This! Search Technorati Tag it on Del.icio.us



Get a Free Sample

Wondering about CMS Watch research? Sign up to receive free samples of any of our products.




What we do

CMS Watch™ evaluates content-oriented technologies, publishing head-to-head comparative reviews of leading solutions. What makes us special?

  • Our critical analysis exposes product weaknesses as well as strengths
  • We deliver unrivaled technical depth and comprehensive project advice
  • Our research is led by international topic experts
  • We only work for buyers -- never for vendors

Contact us

CMS Watch

info@cmswatch.com

18113 Town Center Drive, Ste 217

Olney, MD USA 20832

1 800 325 6190 (customer service)

+1 617 763 5336 (int'l customer service)

Fax: +1 214 242 3048